pretty sure what has scarred me for life is the fatal frame series. fatal frame 4 not so much, since it doesn't have the camera effects of the previous games (where you can see ghosts behind the character while said character isn't looking ugh UGH)

it takes a lot for animanga to scare me, since atmosphere is important to me feeling scared at all. i don't know much about pastas, but here's the shortest horror story ever written to make up for it:

"the last man on earth hears a knock on his door."